Two central banks. No shared ledger. A big lesson for small states

Singapore and Germany have tested cross-border currency settlement without a shared ledger. For small island states, the real opportunity is not just faster payments, but a voice in deciding how tomorrow's financial infrastructure works.

Singapore and Germany's central banks had successfully tested the settlement of euro–Singapore dollar transactions, using wholesale central bank digital currencies. Image: Canva

​

A small country can issue its own currency, run its own central bank, and build a modern national payment system.  


Yet when it needs to pay for imported food, fuel or medicine, it may still depend on banks and infrastructure thousands of kilometres away. 


That is an uncomfortable reality of financial sovereignty. 


On November 16, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) and Germany's Deutsche Bundesbank announced Project Simbolon.  


The two central banks had successfully tested the settlement of euro–Singapore dollar transactions

Former Minister of State for Environment, Climate Change and Technology in the Maldives, Mohamed Shareef.

using wholesale central bank digital currencies. 


Two currencies. Two independent ledgers. No shared platform.


Using a cryptographic technique called zero-knowledge proofs, each system could verify that the conditions for settlement had been met without direct technical integration with the other central bank's ledger.  


Both sides of a currency exchange settle together, or neither does. That removes the risk of one party paying without receiving the other currency. 


This was a controlled experiment, not a live financial service. But its significance extends well beyond Singapore and Germany. 


It challenges the assumption that countries must share financial infrastructure to connect their financial systems. 


For small island states, that distinction matters. 

Connecting is not the same as consolidating 


Much of the conversation around cross-border payments has focused on integration.  


That is connect national systems. Join a regional network. Adopt common infrastructure. Agree on technical standards. 


These approaches can deliver benefits, but they also raise a question for smaller countries: who controls the infrastructure once everyone depends on it? 


A small central bank cannot match the investment, technical workforce or international influence of a major financial centre.  


It needs international connectivity, but it must also preserve its ability to supervise settlement, protect financial stability and enforce domestic law. 


Project Simbolon demonstrates a different architectural choice.  


Instead of placing both currencies on one ledger, the experiment coordinated settlement across independently governed systems. Each central bank retained control of its own ledger and settlement requirements. 


The lesson is not that shared infrastructure is inherently bad. It is that connecting financial systems and consolidating their control are different choices.  


Small countries should be able to evaluate both. 

Why small islands have more at stake 


For large economies, cross-border payments are an efficiency challenge. For many small island economies, they are a question of economic resilience. 


The Maldives earns substantial foreign currency from tourism while depending heavily on imports. Similar dependencies exist across the Pacific and Caribbean. 


International payments rely on correspondent banking relationships, through which domestic banks gain access to financial institutions abroad. These relationships are under pressure. 


The World Bank reported that the Pacific experienced a 60 per cent decline in correspondent banking relationships since 2011, twice the global average.  


A US$77 million (S$99.21 million) regional initiative was launched to help preserve access to international banking services. 


UN Trade and Development has also linked greater losses of correspondent banking relationships in vulnerable developing economies with larger reductions in export growth. 


In the Maldives, foreign currency pressures are familiar.  


In August 2026, the Maldives Monetary Authority temporarily raised its dollar allocations to banks by 51 per cent for three weeks, as businesses struggled to obtain foreign currency for imports. 


Project Simbolon will not solve a shortage of dollars. Nor will cryptography remove the need for correspondent banks, regulatory compliance or access to settlement currencies.  


Simbolon demonstrates an alternative settlement architecture. Independently governed settlement systems could eventually give smaller economies more options for connecting to international markets. 


Whether that architecture ultimately benefits small economies will depend less on the cryptography than on who can access it, what participation costs and how its rules are governed. 

The Maldives already has a starting point 


In September 2021, during a national consultation organised with UN DESA and UN ESCAP, the Maldives selected central bank digital currency as a focus for frontier technology policy experimentation. 


A national study on CBDC and stablecoins followed in 2022. Maldivian officials then took part in learning exchanges with the Republic of Korea and Singapore. 


On November 12, 2023, regulatory sandbox guidelines for CBDC and FinTech were published for the Maldives Monetary Authority, developed through cooperation involving the MMA, UN DESA, ESCAP and the Ministry of Environment, Climate Change and Technology. 


I worked on that programme during my tenure as Minister of State. 


The main outcome was never meant to be a digital rufiyaa in everyone's wallet.  


It was the institutional capacity to experiment safely with financial technologies, understand their risks and make informed regulatory decisions. 


Those guidelines do not, by themselves, mean that an operational sandbox or wholesale settlement pilot exists today. But they give the Maldives a foundation from which to evaluate one. 


Real progress has also occurred in payments.  


In July 2026, the Maldives connected its Favara instant payment system with India's UPI, starting with real-time person-to-person transfers from the Maldives to India. That is a significant achievement, though it serves a different purpose from Simbolon's wholesale settlement experiment. 


It also shows the limits of a bilateral approach. A small economy cannot negotiate and maintain a separate corridor with every trading partner.  


Multilateral connectivity matters, and so does a say in its terms. 

The technology worked. The difficult questions remain


There is a danger in celebrating technological breakthroughs before examining what they actually prove. 


The Project Simbolon Insights Note identifies several limitations.  


Generating cryptographic proofs accounted for most of the end-to-end settlement time. Any future system must establish how settlement is recognised as final under the applicable legal frameworks.


And the system still depends on operators to generate and transmit proofs. 


The test demonstrated technical feasibility, not a complete operational or governance solution. That is precisely why small countries should be interested now. 


The next phase involves deciding who can participate, how settlement becomes legally final, who operates critical services, what information they can access and how disputes are resolved.  


These are governance decisions with long-term consequences. 


The greatest risk for small states is that they will adopt rules they had no opportunity to shape.

Small states need a seat before the rules are written 


The Maldives and other small island economies should pursue three practical priorities. 


First, move from studying digital currencies to testing specific settlement problems.  


Building on existing regulatory work, a limited wholesale experiment with a willing partner could examine interoperability, legal finality, liquidity requirements and operational resilience.  

The objective should be evidence. 


Second, participate early in international design discussions.  


Nexus Global Payments, targeting its first live deployment in 2027, will connect domestic instant payment systems. Singapore's Project Guardian brings policymakers and industry together on asset tokenisation. Simbolon addresses wholesale settlement.  


Standards are forming in all three, and smaller economies need to understand them before they become entrenched. 


Third, collaborate across small states.  


Individual island central banks may struggle to support specialised experimentation alone.  


Shared technical expertise, regional testing arrangements and common policy positions would strengthen their hand with larger financial markets. 


These steps require sustained institutional attention and a willingness to engage before decisions are final. 

Before the design is finished 


Project Simbolon is not yet a solution for small island economies. It has not demonstrated live settlement, lower correspondent banking costs or access for small currencies. 


But it has shown that independently governed financial infrastructures can coordinate settlement without operating on a shared ledger. 


The financial infrastructure of the next decade is being designed today. Small states should not wait for an invitation once it is finished. 


We do not need to own every part of the global financial system. But we should have a say in the rules governing the parts we cannot live without. 


----------------------------------------------


The author is the former Minister of State for Environment, Climate Change and Technology in the Maldives (2021-2023). He previously served as Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Communications, Science and Technology (2019-2021) and as Chief Information Officer at the National Centre for Information Technology (2009-2014), where he led the development of the country's national digital public infrastructure. He has also worked in academia, including as a researcher at the United Nations University. He is the Founder of the Island Digital Futures Institute. More of his work is at mshareef.mv.